User avatar
SJConspirator
20 Jun 2021 07:35 pm
SJConspirator
User avatar
If that is true, how does a liberal differ from a Anarchist? I think liberalism is perfectly in accord with government as long that government has liberal policies, as Dantev pointed out.    ...
— LiberalForum Archive
User avatar
FOS
20 Jun 2021 07:30 pm
FOS
User avatar
I guess I could say, lol, that you are walking a fine line here between the no true Scotsman fallacy and the argument from popularity fallacy.  Like no...let's not commit either fallacy. Liberalism should be defined by is philosophical priors. 'government is bad' is indeed one of those priors.   ...
— LiberalForum Archive
User avatar
Cannonpointer
20 Jun 2021 07:30 pm
Cannonpointer
User avatar
A semantic disagreement. I will adopt your terminology. Props for knowing about Huey Long....
— LiberalForum Archive
User avatar
Rock
20 Jun 2021 07:29 pm
Rock
User avatar
Yes. Yes he did. Thanks for agreeing.   ...
— LiberalForum Archive
User avatar
Phoenix68.2.0
20 Jun 2021 07:27 pm
Phoenix68.2.0
User avatar
  Oh...please....not audits, again.....what will we ever do? . https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h4xsDTpxrLo...
— LiberalForum Archive
User avatar
Blackvegetable
20 Jun 2021 07:24 pm
Blackvegetable
User avatar
Because Grifty had EARNED a 2nd term?...
— LiberalForum Archive
User avatar
FOS
20 Jun 2021 07:14 pm
FOS
User avatar
My argument also is based on the fact that words ought to have actual meaning, lol if you cannot define a political philosophy independently of who labels themselves that philosophy then you can't even talk about politics anymore....
— LiberalForum Archive
User avatar
Polar1ty
20 Jun 2021 07:14 pm
Polar1ty
User avatar
I was specifically referring to 'internal' opposition to FDR among his supporters. Obviously the Rockefellers and DuPonts don't fall under that category as generally industrialists back in 1933 weren't FDR liberals (or if they were they did it for cynical/self serving reasons and not because they s...
— LiberalForum Archive
User avatar
Polar1ty
20 Jun 2021 07:12 pm
Polar1ty
User avatar
Then your argument is that more people would support fascism/fascism-lite if it wasn't made into the f word of politics, which is different from people who argue that (subset) isn't liberal because (reasons). In fact your argument implies that people who oppose the current system CANNOT be liberals...
— LiberalForum Archive
User avatar
Rock
20 Jun 2021 07:10 pm
Rock
User avatar
Just a hunch....
— LiberalForum Archive